Top 10 Songs From 50 Artists

 DISCLAIMER: The following is subject to change as my opinions continue to evolve.

Awhile back I got bored and started making Top 10 song lists of all my favorite artists (mostly rock, but some hip hop artists too, and even a few pop guilty pleasures). Having now come up with such lists for fifty music artists in total, I thought it’d be cool to share them here. And for the record: Yes, all these artists are arrange in chronological order from whenever each of them released their first albums (I think).

So, without further ado… Here you go:

The Beatles

1.Let It Be (Single Version), 2.Yesterday, 3.Revolution, 4.Day Tripper, 5.Here Comes the Sun, 6.Come Together, 7.While My Guitar Gently Weeps, 8.With a Little Help from My Friends, 9.Hey Jude, 10.Get Back

The Rolling Stones

1.Gimme Shelter, 2.Wild Horses, 3.Angie, 4.You Can’t Always Get What You Want, 5.Paint It Black, 6.Sympathy for the Devil, 7.Beast of Burden, 8.Miss You, 9.Jumpin’ Jack Flash, 10.Start Me Up

Jimi Hendrix

1.Voodoo Child (Slight Return), 2.Burning of the Midnight Lamp, 3.All Along the Watchtower, 4.Little Wing, 5.Castles Made of Sand, 6.Ezy Ryder, 7.Foxey Lady, 8.Fire, 9.The Wind Cries Mary, 10.Are You Experienced?

Led Zeppelin

1.No Quarter, 2.D’yer Mak’er, 3.All My Love, 4.Battle of Evermore, 5.When the Levee Breaks, 6.Out on the Tiles, 7.Immigrant Song (Live), 8.Trampled Under Foot, 9.Babe I’m Gonna Leave You, 10.Ramble On

Black Sabbath

1.Supernaut, 2.Symptom of the Universe, 3.Sabbra Cadabra, 4.Sabbath Bloody Sabbath, 5.Children of the Grave, 6.War Pigs / Luke’s Wall, 7.Paranoid, 8.Iron Man, 9.Jack the Stripper / Fairies Wear Boots, 10.Wheels of Confusion / The Straightener, Honorable Mention: A National Acrobat

Michael Jackson

1.Thriller, 2.Wanna Be Startin’ Somethin’, 3.Beat It, 4.Billie Jean, 5.Dirty Diana, 6.In the Closet, 7.Give Into Me, 8.Jam, 9.P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing), 10.Invincible, Honorable Mention: Blood on the Dancefloor

ABBA

1.Dancing Queen, 2.SOS, 3.Mama Mia, 4.Take a Chance on Me, 5.Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! (A Man After Midnight), 6.Waterloo, 7.Super Trouper, 8.The Winner Takes It All, 9.Chiquitita, 10.Voulez-Vous

Aerosmith

1.Rats in the Cellar, 2.Back in the Saddle, 3.Sick as a Dog, 4.Last Child, 5.Dream On, 6.Mama Kin, 7.Sweet Emotion, 8.Walk This Way, 9.Water Song/ Janie’s Got a Gun, 10.Lord of the Thighs

Queen

1.The Show Must Go On, 2.A Kind of Magic, 3.I Want It All, 4.I Want to Break Free, 5.Radio Ga Ga, 6.Killer Queen, 7.Stone Cold Crazy, 8.Don’t Stop Me Now, 9.Bohemian Rhapsody, 10.Love of My Life

Kiss

1.I Stole Your Love, 2.Love Her All I Can, 3.Detroit Rock City (2012 Remix), 4.Hard Luck Woman, 5.Unholy, 6.Tears Are Falling, 7.Creatures of the Night (1985 Remix), 8.Black Diamond, 9. Parasite, 10.I Was Made for Lovin’ You

Van Halen

1.Ain’t Talkin’ ‘Bout Love, 2.Little Dreamer, 3.Unchained, 4.Panama, 5.Hang ‘em High, 6.Little Guitars, 7.DOA, 8.Everybody Wants Some, 9.Atomic Punk, 10.Mean Street

Def Leppard

1.Bringin’ on the Heartbreak, 2.Switch 625, 3.Two Steps Behind (Acoustic), 4.Love Bites, 5.Hysteria, 6.Foolin’, 7.Photograph, 8.Rocket, 9.Miss You in a Heartbeat (Revised), 10.Pour Some Sugar on Me

Ozzy Osbourne

1.No More Tears, 2.Hellraiser, 3.Diary of a Madman, 4.Believer, 5.You’re No Different, 6.The Ultimate Sin, 7.Miracle Man, 8.Mr. Crowley, 9.Bark at the Moon, 10.Shot in the Dark (Live & Loud Version)

U2

1.The Fly, 2.Until the End of the World, 3.New Year’s Day (Video Version), 4.Bullet the Blue Sky, 5.Pride (In the Name of Love), 6.Vertigo, 7.Stuck in a Moment You Can’t Get Out Of, 8.Walk On, 9.Original of the Species, 10.Mysterious Ways

Metallica

1.Ride the Lightning, 2.For Whom the Bell Tolls, 3.Fade to Black, 4.Battery, 5.Orion, 6.Through the Never, 7.Enter Sandman, 8.One, 9.The Thing that Should Not Be, 10.Hardwired

Pantera

1.Cemetery Gates, 2.Cowboys from Hell, 3.A New Level, 4.Mouth for War, 5.5 Minutes Alone, 6.I’m Broken, 7.Walk, 8.Death Rattle, 9.Yesterday Don’t Mean Shit, 10.This Love, Honorable Mention: Regular People (Conceit)

The Smiths

1.How Soon Is Now?, 2.What Difference Does It Make?, 3.Handsome Devil, 4.This Charming Man, 5.William It Was Really Nothing, 6.Hand in Glove (Hatful of Hollow Version), 7.Heaven Knows I’m Miserable Now, 8.There Is A Light That Never Goes Out, 9.Still Ill, 10.Well I Wonder

Red Hot Chili Peppers

1.Scar Tissue, 2.Under the Bridge, 3.Dark Necessities, 4.Minor Thing, 5.Backwoods, 6.The Shape I’m Takin’, 7.Death of a Martian, 8.Quixoticelixer, 9.This Is the Kitt, 10.Look Around, Honorable Mention: Black Summer

Faith No More

1.Kindergarten, 2.Everything’s Ruined, 3.Midlife Crisis, 4.A Small Victory, 5.From Out of Nowhere, 6.Ashes to Ashes, 7.Cuckoo for Caca, 8.The Gentle Art of Making Enemies, 9.King for a Day, 10.The Perfect Crime, Honorable Mention: Absolute Zero

Guns N’ Roses

1.November Rain, 2.Rocket Queen, 3.Nightrain, 4.Mr. Brownstone, 5.Out ta Get Me, 6.Sweet Child o’ Mine, 7.You Could Be Mine, 8.Yesterdays, 9.This I Love, 10.Dead Horse

Soundgarden

1.Limo Wreck, 2.The Day I Tried to Live, 3.Let Me Drown, 4.Superunknown, 5.Mailman, 6.Room a Thousand Years Wide, 7.Holy Water, 8.Jesus Christ Pose, 9.Burden in My Hand, 10.Big Dumb Sex, Honorable Mention: Blow Up the Outside World

Nine Inch Nails

1.Head Like a Hole, 2.Closer, 3.March of the Pigs, 4.Hurt, 5.Mr. Self-Destruct, 6.1000000000, 7.Echoplex, 8.Down in It, 9.Terrible Lie, 10.The Perfect Drug, Honorable Mention: Sin

Nirvana

1.Come As You Are, 2.Polly, 3.Very Ape, 4.Dumb, 5.Dive, 6.Lounge Act, 7.Sappy, 8.Do Re Mi, 9.Blew, 10.All Apologies, Honorable Mention: You Know You’re Right

Green Day

1.Geek Stink Breath, 2.Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams, 3.Whatsername, 4.American Idiot, 5.Wake Me Up When September Ends, 6.Longview, 7.Welcome to Paradise, 8.Basket Case, 9.When I Come Around, 10.Good Riddance (Time of Your Life)

Alice in Chains

1.Bleed the Freak, 2.Sunshine, 3.Would?, 4.Angry Chair, 5.Them Bones, 6.Rooster, 7.God Smack, 8.Dirt, 9.Rotten Apple, 10.Nutshell, Honorable Mention: The One You Know

The Smashing Pumpkins

1.Mayonaise, 2.Cherub Rock, 3.Drown, 4.1979, 5.Bullet with Butterfly Wings, 6.An Ode to No One, 7.Thirty-Three, 8.Rhinoceros, 9.Quiet, 10.Eye

Pearl Jam

1.Black, 2.Alive, 3.Jeremy, 4.Deep, 5.Even Flow (Single Version), 6.Yellow Ledbetter, 7.Rearviewmirror, 8.Go, 9.Daughter, 10.Better Man

No Doubt

1.Don’t Speak, 2.Sunday Morning, 3.Just a Girl, 4.Spiderwebs, 5.Trapped in a Box, 6.Hella Good, 7.Underneath It All, 8.Hey Baby, 9.It’s My Life, 10.Love to Love You Baby

Rage Against the Machine

1.Bulls on Parade, 2.Bombtrack, 3.Know Your Enemy, 4.Guerilla Radio, 5.Killing in the Name, 6.Take the Power Back, 7.Testify, 8.Sleep Now in the Fire, 9.Bullet in the Head, 10.How I Could Just Kill a Man

Stone Temple Pilots

1.Crackerman, 2.Sex Type Thing, 3.Trippin’ on a Hole in a Paper Heart, 4.Meadow, 5.Naked Sunday, 6.Dead & Bloated, 7.Interstate Love Song, 8.Vasoline, 9.Plush, 10.Piece of Pie, Honorable Mention: Creep

Dr. Dre

1.Nuthin’ but a “G” Thang, 2.Fuck Wit Dre Day (And Everybody’s Celebratin’), 3.Let Me Ride, 4.Forgot About Dre, 5.Still DRE, 6.The Next Episode, 7.What’s the Difference?, 8.I Need A Doctor, 9.Just Another Day (performed by The Game), 10.Talk About It

Buckethead

1.Nottingham Lace, 2.Big Sur Moon, 3.Claymation Courtyard, 4.Griffin’s Spike, 5.Big D’s Touch, 6.Binge & Grab, 7.Electric Umbrella, 8.Mind Train, 9.Our Selves, 10.Pink Eye, Honorable Mention: Last Light

Tool

1.The Pot, 2.Forty-Six & 2, 3.Swamp Song, 4.Sober, 5.Intolerance, 6.Prison Sex, 7.Bottom, 8.Schism, 9.Jambi, 10.Descending

Oasis

1.Champagne Supernova, 2.Cast No Shadow, 3.Morning Glory, 4.Live Forever, 5.Supersonic (Live), 6.Don’t Look Back in Anger, 7.Talk Tonight, 8.Slide Away, 9.Falling Down, 10.I’m Outta Time

Weezer

1.Island in the Sun, 2.Say It Ain’t So, 3.Undone - The Sweater Song, 4.Buddy Holly, 5.The Good Life, 6.Hash Pipe, 7.Pork and Beans, 8.Beverly Hills, 9.Only in Dreams, 10.All My Favorite Songs

Outkast

1.Rosa Parks, 2.B.O.B. (Bombs Over Baghdad), 3.Ms. Jackson, 4.SpottieOttieDopaliscious, 5.ATLiens, 6.Southernplayalisticadillacmuzik, 7.So Fresh So Clean, 8.The Way You Move, 9.Aquemini, 10.Skew It on the Bar-B, Honorable Mention: In Your Dreams

John Frusciante

1.Away & Anywhere, 2.Representing, 3.Murderers, 4.Look On, 5.Loss, 6.Untitled #7, 7.Cut Out, 8.Second Walk, 9.Song to Sing When I’m Lonely, 10.Every Person, Honorable Mention: Smile from the Streets You Hold

Foo Fighters

1.Dear Rosemary, 2.Wind Up, 3.Hey Johnny Park, 4.Everlong, 5.Stranger Things Have Happened, 6.Generator, 7.Headwires, 8.I’ll Stick Around, 9.Aurora, 10.February Stars, Honorable Mention: Gimme Stitches

Eminem

1.Stan, 2.Without Me, 3.Lose Yourself, 4.White America, 5.Cleanin’ Out My Closet, 6.The Real Slim Shady, 7.My Name Is, 8.Guilty Conscience, 9.Role Model, 10.Bad Meets Evil

Daft Punk

1.Harder Better Faster Stronger, 2.One More Time, 3.Aerodynamic, 4.Da Funk, 5.Around the World, 6.Instant Crush, 7.Get Lucky, 8.Robot Rock, 9.Lose Yourself to Dance, 10.Contact

System of a Down

1.Ariels, 2.Chop Suey, 3.ATWA, 4.Toxicity, 5.Sugar, 6.Know, 7.Hypnotize, 8.BYOB, 9.Revenga, 10.Prison Song, Honorable Mention: Holy Mountains

Coldplay

1.Violet Hill, 2.Viva la Vida, 3.The Hardest Part, 4.Speed of Sound, 5.The Scientist, 6.Clocks, 7.In My Place, 8.Fix You, 9.Yellow, 10.Adventure of a Lifetime

The White Stripes

1.Fell in Love with a Girl, 2.Blue Orchid, 3.The Denial Twist, 4.Hotel Yorba, 5.Truth Doesn’t Make a Noise, 6.Why Can’t You Be Nicer to Me?, 7.Little Bird, 8.Seven Nation Army, 9.The Hardest Button to Button, 10.Icky Thump, Honorable Mention: Black Math

Slipknot

1.The Heretic Anthem, 2.People = Shit, 3.Solway Firth, 4.Nero Forte, 5.Custer, 6.Sulfur, 7.Psychosocial, 8.(sic), 9.Spit It Out, 10.Duality, Honorable Mention: Left Behind

Linkin Park

1.In the End, 2.A Place for My Head, 3.Faint, 4.Figure-09, 5.Don’t Stay, 6.Lying from You, 7.Across the Line, 8.More the Victim, 9.Castle of Glass, 10.Two Faced

Audioslave

1.Be Yourself, 2.Like a Stone, 3.Show Me How to Live, 4.Set It Off, 5.What You Are, 6.Cochise, 7.Gasoline, 8.I Am the Highway, 9.Heaven’s Dead, 10.Out of Exile

Justin Timberlake

1.Like I Love You, 2.Cry Me a River, 3.Rock Your Body, 4.FutureSex / LoveSound, 5.SexyBack, 6.Medley: Let Me Talk to You / My Love, 7.What Goes Around… / …Comes Around (Interlude), 8.LoveStoned / I Think She Knows (Interlude), 9.Suit & Tie, 10.Can’t Stop the Feeling

Velvet Revolver

1.Fall to Pieces, 2.Slither, 3.Set Me Free, 4.Illegal i-Song, 5.Headspace, 6.Sucker Train Blues, 7.Get Out the Door, 8.Messages, 9.She Builds Quick Machines, 10.Can’t Get It Out of My Head, Honorable Mention: Gravedancer

Slash

1.Standing in the Sun, 2.Anastasia, 3.Been There Lately, 4.Life’s Sweet Drug, 5.Shine, 6.Shadow Life, 7.Wicked Stone, 8.Bent to Fly, 9.Lower, 10.Mean Bone

Jack White

1.Over and Over and Over, 2.Love Is Selfish, 3.Bombing Out, 5.Archbishop Harold Holmes, 5.That’s How I’m Feeling, 6.Old Scratch Blues, 7.Lazaretto, 8.Hip (Eponymous) Poor Boy, 9.Blunderbuss, 10.Freedom at 21, Honorable Mention: Fear of the Dawn

There you have it!

Peace!

Related Article: Top 10 Songs From Even More Artists

My Pitch for the Future of Star Wars

  So the other day I was on the Star Wars fan forums website theforce.net and there was a thread on there asking fans to speculate what Star Wars content set after The Rise of Skywalker might be like. Some of the comments from other users on there inspired me to come up with a hypothetical roadmap for various post-Skywalker Saga projects. I shared my outline on the forum and a few people there said they liked what I had in mind, so I figured I might as well share all of my ideas here too. Keep in mind that I do not expect Lucasfilm to actually do any of this stuff. This is all just for fun.

Before we begin, though, allow me to clarify a few things. First of all; I think Star Wars has outgrown the “trilogy structure,” at this point. I have some ideas for three shows as well as three live-action films, but each project would theoretically stand on it’s own, so that they could be made in almost any order (some may not have to even be made at all). Furthermore, the only sequel trilogy characters I have ideas for are Rey, Finn and (to a lesser extent) Rose. Nothing against the other characters. I just don’t know where their stories can go. Also, I know John Boyega said in mid 2020 that he was done with Star Wars, but he has since walked back on those comments and recently said he was open to returning. For some reason the press didn’t really run with that story, though (probably because it doesn’t fit the narrative of “Disney ruined Star Wars”).

With that all being said, here’s my pitch for what post-Rise of Skywalker content could look like. Part of me actually still feels that all of this is stupid, but I’m gonna share it anyway, so here it goes:

ANIMATED SHOW 1

Working title:

Star Wars: Regions of the Galaxy

Rough idea: 

Starts a few years after The Rise of Skywalker. There’s no galactic-wide government of any kind anymore. The Resistance managed to gain control of the Core Region of the galaxy and have since evolved into The Core Republic. Other parts of the galaxy are controlled by other factions (Mandalorians, crime syndicates, maybe even new versions of stuff like the Nihil and Nightsisters, etc.). So I guess if this “Age” needed a name it would be “Age of Divide” or something like that. There are no remnants of the Sith, Knights of Ren, Empire, First Order or Final Order whatsoever. The closest we get to that is whatever Thrawn has going on in the Unknown Regions (assuming he’s even still alive by this point). I also like the idea of one of the factions experimenting with cloning again, maybe even perfecting force-sensitive clones. But that’s not essential. I also like the droid revolt idea (mentioned by someone else on the forum).

Rey and Finn are restarting the Jedi order in two different ways; one of them is gathering small children like Broom Boy and training them slowly in a school-like environment, and the other is speed-training about half-a-dozen or so other adults and they’re all going on adventures (sometimes together and sometimes apart) in a Knights-of-the-Round-Table type of fashion. 

Right now I’m leaning towards Finn being the one mainly training the adults (and show Rey training him beforehand through flashbacks). I want to use this show as an opportunity to “move him further along.” Maybe he rekindles the flame he briefly had with Rose on Crait and takes her last name (or finally finds out what his real name was). Maybe he meets one or more of the ghosts. You get the idea. He’s “the field agent” and Rey is “the Yoda.” And not that it matters, but as far as saber colors go, I always thought green would suit Finn.

I wouldn’t have a central conflict or war or anything driving the show forward like that. Just keep it loose and episodic. The main purpose of this show is just worldbuilding and laying the groundwork for the future.

LIVE-ACTION MOVIE 1

Working title: 

Star Wars: Alliance

Rough idea: 

It’s been like five or ten years now since The Rise of Skywalker. If Lucasfilm wants they can make this movie first and then make the show described above afterwards to “fill in the gaps” between The Rise of Skywalker and this.

In short; characters from the sequel trilogy team up with characters from The Mandalorian and its “sister shows.” So it’s basically a crossover, of sorts, between the Skywalker Saga and the Mandoverse. I think that would be a neat way to bring back sequel trilogy characters (mainly Rey) in a live-action movie without undoing the idea of The Rise of Skywalker being the end of the Skywalker Saga. It’s not really what I would want, personally, but it would probably put butts in seats, which is what Disney is thinking about.

I would have Rey team up with Din Djarin specifically (who I assume is ruling Mandalore at this point), to really emphasize this “crossover” idea as much as possible. I know he’d be like 70-75 at this point, so maybe keep his helmet on the whole time and just have Pedro Pascal limp around and say something along the lines of “I may be old but I still got a few tricks up my sleeve,” just not in those exact words (cause that would be stupid). Alternatively, just have him “sitting around” and have Rey instead pair up with Sabine, who would probably also need to be played by a different actress at this point, or at least keep her helmet on the whole time too.

The main conflict would involve an outside-galaxy threat. Let’s just say the Grysk, for now (assuming the Mandoverse “big storytelling event” that Lucasfilm talked about doesn’t involve them first). For context; the Grysk are a new alien race that have been loosely mentioned in recent books as “a half-myth,” and they haven’t really been officially detected yet. Apparently they may or may not come from a different galaxy, and are described as “invaders.” The old Expanded Universe novels (now called Legends) had something similar to this.

I don’t know if I would flat-out say they come from a different galaxy, though. I would just “loosely imply” it, if that makes sense. Either way, the Jedi find out about the Grysk so they have to split up to go recruit all the other political factions outside of The Core Republic. It’s not the end of the Age of Divide, just a brief unification against this new exterior threat, is all.

Also, just to be a bit more “thematic” with the idea of divisions and factions, I would have Rey and Finn start to not get along at this point, because they have different ideas on how the Jedi should continue to evolve. They manage to put their differences aside for the climax of the movie, of course, but the very end of the story hints that the Jedi of the future may have similar differences, which they accept. This is to hint that the Jedi in centuries from now may be separated into several different factions with no centralization.

ANIMATED SHOW 2

Working title:

Star Wars: Fallout

Rough idea:

The purpose of this show would be to explore how the galaxy deals with the ongoing aftermath of the Grysk invasion. At this point I would start to move the sequel trilogy characters to the background, and focus on new heroes instead.

LIVE-ACTION MINISERIES

Working title:

Star Wars: Unity

Rough idea:

The purpose of this project would be to bring Rey and Finn back one more time after not having seen them again for a while, for a “farewell.” I imagine them being middle-aged at this point, and imply that they’ve now been fully estranged from one another for at least a few years. They each have their own isolated Jedi orders now (a further sign of what’s to come). Both characters are put in a position where they have to come together one last time. They both die together in a self-sacrificial way at the end of the miniseries, but they clearly forgive one another and are good friends again in the final moments. Their Jedi orders have a newfound respect for one another after this, but continue to remain separate.

        I understand the idea of Rey and Finn dying at the same time may sound pretty dark for Star Wars standards, but my gut tells me it would make sense. They started their “Jedi journeys” together, so might as well also end together, right? Also, the reason I would want this to be a live-action miniseries instead of a film is because I feel like doing this particular story as a film would feel too much like “Skywalker Saga Episode 10,” which I’m trying to avoid cause I still want The Rise of Skywalker to feel like an ending.

LIVE-ACTION MOVIE 2

Working title:

Star Wars: Jedi Legacy

Rough idea:

Set like a thousand years later, the Jedi have evolved into several different factions with no centralization, and each faction has a slightly different philosophy from one another. Meanwhile, the political factions are all unified back together now, and call themselves The Alliance (as a reference to the film described above). So this would be the “Age of Alliance.” Basically everyone hates the Jedi for not being able to get along now. This is where the Sith would come back, in some fashion. I would bring back Matt Smith’s “Sith King” character (an amalgamation of all dead Sith) that got cut from The Rise of Skywalker, and maybe have him act a little like Palpatine, to imply that good ol’ Sheev is “still in there somewhere.” As expected, all the different Jedi factions realize they gotta come together, but in order to do so, they need to dig deep and figure out secrets about how the Jedi first began “thousands of generations ago,” which leads us to…

LIVE-ACTION MOVIE 3

Working title:

Star Wars: Jedi Origins

Rough idea:

Okay, this one doesn’t actually take place after The Rise of Skywalker, but rather thousands of generations before anything we know from canon Star Wars. That said, it would still be “spiritually connected,” in a sense, to the film described above. It would basically be the Dawn of the Jedi comics from Legends, but as a movie. I know there’s rumors that this is what Taika Waititi’s film is gonna be. We’ll see what happens, I guess…

Alright, that’s all I got!

Peace!

Related: Fiction Repository

DUNE: Battle of the Adaptations

  A couple of weeks ago, director Denis Villeneuve’s long-awaited adaptation of the Frank Herbet sci-fi novel Dune (or the first half of it, at least) was finally released in theaters here in the US, and as of this writing, I finally had a chance to see it over the weekend. In the days leading up to the screening, I decided to immerse myself into Dune lore by watching all of the previous adaptations, as well as the 2013 documentary Jodorowsky’s Dune, about a canceled film adaptation of the story from the 1970’s that would’ve been made by Chile’s favorite surrealist, Alejandro Jodorowsky. I had also wanted to read the book, but didn’t find the time (been busy lately), so instead I looked up some notes and talked to several people I know who happened to have read it in the past.

So now that I’ve done my homework (or as much of it as I can, up until this point), I thought it would be fun to compare all the different cinematic adaptations of the book that we’ve had thus far, and explain which version I think is the ideal one, and why.

With that being said, let’s go ride some sandworms…

David Lynch’s Dune (1984)

Background: When experimental filmmaker and cult hero David Lynch was first approached to adapt Dune, he hadn’t even read it. The fact that he even agreed to do it is a bit of a shock, since he had just turned down directing Return of the Jedi because George Lucas showed him a picture of Chewbacca and it “gave him a headache.” What won him over was the fact that the studio promised to fund his next film, Blue Velvet, once Dune was complete. After working his way through the book, Lynch wrote the screenplay all on his own, which itself is pretty impressive, since he wasn’t even familiar with the source material beforehand. Once filming had wrapped, Lynch put together a rough cut that was about four or five hours long, and proposed splitting all the footage into two separate movies. Since this wasn’t the norm at the time, the studio rejected his proposal, and instead trimmed all of his footage down to a single two-hour film that ended up bombing both critically and financially upon release. Needless to say, Lynch didn’t take this well, and says he still regrets ever getting involved with Dune to this very day.

Greatest Strength: As flawed as it may be, it’s nice to have a version of this entire story that can be digested in just two hours. It’s extremely hard to follow if you’re a newbie to the Dune lore, of course, but for “seasoned veterans,” it’s a convenient way of reliving the tale without having to invest too much time into it (again).

Greatest Weakness: This isn’t really a true Dune adaptation, per se, but rather David Lynch’s “reimagining” of it. If you’re a fan of his unique style in general, that may not be too bothersome for you, but those looking for something more “in-line” with the book can expect to be disappointed. Personally, I’m someone who considers themes to be the most important aspect of any story, and what I find fascinating about the original Dune novel (what I understand from it, at least) is that it deconstructs the theme of “what it means to be a messiah.” In other words, it critiques “the hero’s journey,” before Star Wars even made “the hero’s journey” cool. That’s why that book was so ahead of its time, and why it still holds up now. None of those things are anywhere to be found in this film version, though. Did Lynch overlook these details? Or did he omit them intentionally due to external constraints? We’ll likely never know. That said, if you treat this film as its own thing, and if you’re able to get past how rushed it all feels, it’s actually not that bad. While I’m slowly becoming a fan of the source material, I’m also a fan of Lynch as a director, and can appreciate his unique “taste” that he put into this project (weirding modules and all!). Hell, even Herbert himself said he liked the movie and didn’t mind the artistic liberties that it took.

Alan Smithee’s Dune: Extended Edition (1988)

Background: This is actually just a three-hour version of the Lynch film, with about an hour’s worth of deleted scenes added back in, first broadcasted on television in two parts. By this point, however, Lynch himself had long since disowned the project, and therefore asked for this new cut to give the directorial credit to “Alan Smithee” (a name often used by filmmakers who are ashamed of their own work). For the writing credit, Lynch used “Judas Booth” (a combination of Judas Iscariot and John Wilkes Booth).

Greatest Strength: Obviously, it’s a lot less rushed and more coherent than the theatrical version, meaning certain plot holes are now resolved, while Lynch’s sense of charming zaniness is still maintained. That said, the movie still fails to emulate many of the unique themes from the book.

Greatest Weakness: One of the biggest differences between the theatrical cut and this version is the beginning. Instead of the monologue from the Emperor’s daughter (which itself is already awkward if you’re not familiar with the book), we’re treated to a seven-minute long worldbuilding narration that uses concept art to try to get viewers to better understand how exactly this fictional universe works. While I admire the effort, I personally find worldbuilding of this scale to often be one of the least important aspects of telling a story (at least cinematically). When I don’t understand how a world works, I’m usually fine with just correcting things in my head using “the Star Wars excuse” (a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away a.k.a “this doesn’t need to make any sense”). The book definitely deserves praise for just how dense its own lore is, but I have yet to see worldbuilding of that magnitude done well in a cinematic format (even the new 2021 adaptation omitted some of these details).

John Harrison’s Frank Herbert’s Dune (2000)

Background: Around the turn of the millennium, the infamous Sci-Fi channel (known today as Syfy) teamed up with director John Harrison to take a crack at Dune in the form of a TV miniseries. With book fans still burned over the Lynch version(s), Sci-Fi was determined to create an on-screen take more accurate to the source material, even going as far as to name the project Frank Herbert’s Dune to emphasize this.

Greatest Strength: As of right now, this is still the most faithful adaptation of the book, though Villeneuve’s upcoming Dune: Part Two will likely render this one as mostly obsolete. Nevertheless, this take managed to finally capture the core themes of the original story accurately, among other factors (Chani is more likable and closer to her book counterpart here than in either Lynch cut, for instance). That said, I feel this adaptation might’ve been a little too faithful. It’s a common saying that not everything always translates well between mediums, and this is a solid example of that. For instance, the names “Mahdi” and “Maud’Dib” are very frequently used interchangeably for Paul, which may read well, but when having to hear the dialogue instead, I often found myself struggling to know which of those two names were actually being said. Paul also comes across as way more “flat” here, which I know was intentional for the book, but doesn’t really work on screen (the weird casting choice for him didn’t help either, no offense to that actor). That all being said, the miniseries does take a few artistic liberties that allow it to have a bit of its own “identity.” The biggest example of that being the subplot that was added for the Emperor’s daughter, which makes her a more fleshed-out character (though Lady Margot is cut, as a result). Rabban also gets a bit more to do here too, and it all works to further emphasize the “chess game structure” of the story, even if it drags a bit.

Greatest Weakness: As one would expect from a Sci-Fi Channel project, this miniseries was made on a budget of almost nothing, so it looks awful. The sets are trash, the costumes are trash, the effects are trash… I can go on. I suppose one cool feature was how all the night scenes had both blue and green lighting, since the two moons of Arrakis are supposed to be blue and green, respectively. Sadly, it’s still not enough to salvage the overall visuals. I’ve heard people say that this adaptation is best when you pretend it’s just a stage play that just so happened to have a camera in front of it. Seeing it that way definitely helped, but not by much. Thankfully, the 2003 sequel miniseries, which combined the second and third books together, is a vast improvement visually.

Frank Pavich’s Jodorowsky’s Dune (2013)

Background: As mentioned above, surrealist filmmaker Alejandro Jodorowsky tried to get a Dune adaptation off the ground in the 1970’s, but things fell apart. This documentary by Frank Pavich is the closest glimpse we have to what that movie would’ve been like. Things got out of hand pretty fast. Salvador Dali, who would’ve played the Emperor, demanded to be paid $100,000 an hour, while Orson Welles, who would’ve played Baron Harkonnen, demanded to have expensive gourmet dinners cooked for him every single night as part of the movie’s budget. Jodorowsky himself was guilty of some of this disaster too. He casted his own son as the lead, despite the boy only being twelve at the time, and put him through two years worth of martial arts training for six hours a day. Jodo also demanded that the studio allow him to make the final cut of the movie ten hours long. Needless to say, the project died right then and there, but it wasn’t a total waste. During the pre-production period, over three-thousand pieces of concept art were produced and put together as a hardcover book that got passed around Hollywood for the next few years, influencing many of the sci-fi and fantasy films that took the world by storm in the late 70’s and early 80’s. That very same artbook actually sold for over $42,000 at an auction just a few years ago. Jodo himself would also go on to use many of his ideas for Dune in several graphic novels about his own original characters.

Greatest Strength: This entire movie would’ve been very different from the book, and the ending in particular was going to be something not seen in the source material at all. Paul was going to die, and then his consciousness was going to be split into a million pieces, all of which would then be “absorbed” by everyone else on Arrakis. The idea here being that in order for Paul to fulfill the prophecy of the chosen one, he would need to sacrifice himself so that everyone else could instead be the chosen one “in his place.” So, like the book, this adaptation would have been all about deconstructing the hero’s journey on a thematic scale. It just, you know, would’ve done it in a completely different way that would’ve destroyed all possibilities for any of the sequels to ever be adapted… Funny enough, after Paul’s soul gets split up like that, Arrakis was gonna somehow magically travel all over the universe at light speed, turning all dead planets it passes into lush environments full of life, before exploding into a supernova. In other words, Arrakis was going to die so that all other planets could have life, just like how this movie project itself needed to die in order to give life to Alien, The Fifth Element, etc.

Greatest Weakness: Well, in case it wasn’t already obvious, this isn’t really Dune. I understand that it’s important to take some creative license when adapting someone else’s work, but after so many changes, you might as well just make it your own intellectual property instead. Herbert himself was actually somewhat involved with the development process of this project, and like with Lynch later on, he apparently didn’t mind any of these crazy changes that Jodo wanted to make. That being said, having the original creator’s stamp of approval isn’t really enough, in my opinion. Fans of the book initially tore Lynch’s movie apart. If they had gotten this movie instead, we probably would’ve seen riots on the streets…

Denis Villeneuve’s Dune aka Dune: Part One (2021)

Background: Originally intended to be released in 2020, but delayed an entire year due to a certain pandemic, this adaptation is something of a passion project for Villeneuve, as he had been reading the book repeatedly ever since he was 14. Like Lynch before him, Denis requested that the studio allow him to split the adaptation across two separate films. This time, they agreed, but there was a catch: Part Two would only be approved if Part One did well at the box office first. Thankfully, that proved to be the case, and Part Two is now scheduled for an October 2023 release (my gut is telling me that it’ll be delayed a bit, though), and Denis himself hopes to round off his movie trilogy with an adaptation of the second book, Dune Messiah.

Greatest Strength: So far, Villeneuve has been pretty faithful to the book and it’s themes, and I imagine that’ll continue in Part Two (I doubt we’ll get that orgy scene, though). That and the fact that this movie looks and sounds great and is well-acted pretty much makes this the definitive version, as long as Part Two is able to “round the story out” accordingly. While part of me misses the “dirtiness” of the Lynch version, I would still take this one overall. Furthermore, I’ve seen some people say that Part One doesn’t stand on its own enough, which I personally disagree with. I thought centering that film around Paul and Jessica surviving alone in the desert and culminating with their inauguration into the Fremen was a smart move (that final line from Chani was stupid though, and the fact that Gurney and Thufir both just disappear from the plot was annoying). As a side note, I also liked how this version emphasized how not all of Paul’s visions come true. That helped this film to stand on its own while still maintaining a bit of tension, in my opinion.

Greatest Weakness: So if you’ve read my blog before, you’ll know that I criticized Villeneuve for that temper tantrum he threw last year about his film having a theatrical release and a streaming release at the same time as one another. While I enjoyed this movie way more than I expected to, I still stand by everything I said in that post earlier this year. The guy was acting like people wouldn’t have the option to see it in theaters, which wasn’t the case at all. I understand his frustration with how the hybrid release almost killed his chances of getting to make Part Two, and agree that it was shitty of WB to not at least warn him in advance, but nevertheless, safety comes first. Nothing in life is a guarantee until it actually happens anyways. Hell, maybe the lowered expectations actually helped convince WB to green-light the second half! Besides, I saw the film in theaters with a friend, just to have an excuse to get out and socialize, and while I enjoyed the experience, there was nothing that made me say to myself “Oh my god, I’m so glad I saw this in theaters!!” A bigger screen and surround sound doesn’t really mean anything to me these days. If a movie is good, it’s good, regardless of where and how I see it.

And that’s about all I got! Looking forward to Dune: Part Two.

Peace!

2024 UPDATE: Just saw Dune: Part Two. It wasn’t as accurate of an adaptation as I thought it would be, but quite frankly, it’s all the better for it. Besides, people who want a nearly-book-accurate version can stick to the 2000 miniseries (as long as they don’t mind the bad acting and “no budget” look). Whereas people who want a big-budget, “modernized” version of the story now have the Denis films to embrace, and people who prioritize the “weirdness” of the source material can stick to David Lynch. Those of you who want a version that somehow does all three of those things are out of luck, but maybe in like 30 years they’ll do another miniseries version with a Game of Thrones-level budget, or maybe by that point AI will be advanced enough that everyone can just make their own versions…

About My New Sci-Fi/Fantasy Story Collection

  So at the beginning of this year I released my debut story collection Little Life Lessons: Fifty-Five Super Short Stories and wrote a blog post explaining how it came to be. At the end of that post, I mentioned that I had ideas for similar collections, and that I would begin to work on those. Since then, however, I realized it made more sense to combine all of those ideas into just one anthology… And I’ve now done just that!

Ladies and gentlemen, my sophomore effort, Real Enough: Forty Short Stories & Poems, is now available on Amazon. And just like last time, I thought I’d take the opportunity to make a blog post announcing it.

Unlike Little Life Lessons, which told stories loosely based on my own life and observations of the world, Real Enough consists entirely of science fiction and fantasy entries, split into four sections (Low Fantasy, Sci-Fi On Earth, Sci-Fi In Space, High Fantasy). As you may have noticed from the subtitle, some of these entries (exactly half, as a matter of fact) are actually poems.  All four sections of the book alternate back and forth between prose and poetry. As I mentioned at the end of my post announcing Little Life Lessons, I had wanted to also start experimenting with poetry, and quickly saw an opportunity to express some of my sci-fi/fantasy ideas in the form of narrative poems, rather than prose.

While I’m proud of all forty entries, there are a few in particular that are longer than most. I call these the “flagship stories” of the book:

Soon

Highway to Avalon

Racing Death

Survivortown

Sunrise Order

Next Star Over

The Prince of the Island

Long Gone Magic

And just like last time, the process didn’t go perfectly. With the last book, the italics got lost. This time around, the last line of almost every poem was shifted to the side instead of being centered (all of the poems are supposed to be centered). When I saw that, I said to myself “Eh, screw it. Let people think it’s a stylistic choice or something.” There were also some other errors (extra blank pages at the end, extra margin spacing all around, a few typos in the story Soon, etc.). As I said shortly after I released Little Life Lessons, not everything is going to go according to plan, and as an independent author, you’re gonna have to be okay with that…

Honestly, I don’t have much else to say beyond that. I want to let the book speak for itself, after all! The question now is; what will I do next? And the answer is… I don’t know. I definitely want to keep this blog alive, and might even start posting here more frequently again. As far as other books go though, I think I might take a bit of a break now, before figuring out where to go from here…

In the meantime, if you choose to purchase Real Enough, I would like to thank you. Writing sci-fi/fantasy is something I’ve wanted to do ever since I was a little kid, so I hope you enjoy reading this book, just as much as I’ve enjoyed writing it…

Peace!